Reservation Reservation
Best Restaurant Midtown East
Visit Us
  • 905 1st Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
  • Dinner Time - 04:00 pm – 01:00 am

Seafood Restaurant Midtown NYC: Where the Daily Catch Meets 1st Avenue

November 10, 2026

If you’re looking for a seafood restaurant Midtown NYC that treats fish with real respect, The Alexander deserves a spot on your list. It sits at the corner of 1st Avenue and 51st Street in Midtown East. The idea behind it is simple: start with the freshest catch, then let it shine.

The Alexander, at 905 1st Avenue, is a Mediterranean seafood restaurant with Greek influences. The menu features whole grilled branzino, oysters, crudo, lobster and miso black cod, alongside prime steaks and handmade pastas. Dinner runs daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am, minutes from the UN.

What Makes a Great Seafood Restaurant in Midtown NYC?

Midtown has no shortage of places to eat. Finding one where seafood is the point, not an afterthought, is harder.

A few things separate the real thing from the rest:

  • Fish chosen daily, not pulled from a week-old order
  • Simple cooking that lets the ingredient lead
  • A room that suits a quiet dinner and a celebration alike
  • Service that pays attention without hovering

Alexander covers each of these, and does it without fuss.

The Fresh Catch: Seafood at the Heart of the Menu

Every morning, the kitchen selects the day’s fish and shellfish. Whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond. They’re prepared the Greek way, with citrus, olive oil and herbs.

That restraint matters. When fish is this fresh, heavy sauces only get in the way.

Small Plates to Start

Begin light. The appetizers are small bites with big flavors:

  • Oysters
  • Crudo
  • Ceviche
  • Grilled prawns

Ordering a few to share is the fastest way to read a kitchen. Here, they set the tone for everything that follows.

Mains Worth the Trip

The whole grilled branzino is the dish people talk about, and for good reason. It’s the clearest expression of what this kitchen does well.

Other seafood mains include dorado, snapper, Faroe Island salmon, miso black cod, tuna, scallops and lobster. Can’t decide? The lobster pasta brings the seafood together with the kitchen’s handcrafted Italian pastas.

More Than Seafood: Steaks, Pasta and Something Sweet

Not everyone at the table orders fish, and Alexander plans for that. Prime steaks, including a dry-aged strip, sit comfortably beside the seafood. Seasonal vegetables round out the table.

Save room for baklava. It’s a fitting Greek finish to a Mediterranean meal.

The cooking comes from Master Chef Lorenzo, whose approach the restaurant describes in four words: precision, passion, creativity and elegance.

Wine and Cocktails with a Mediterranean Accent

The bar pours Mediterranean-inspired cocktails made with fresh citrus and herbs, the same flavors that run through the food. The wine and spirits list covers Greek, Italian and international labels.

A practical approach: start with something bright alongside oysters or crudo. Then move to a fuller pour if a steak lands on the table.

The Setting: A Polished Dining Room Near the UN

The dining room is lively and polished, just a few minutes from the UN. It fits the moments Midtown dinners are usually about:

  • Client dinners and business meals
  • Pre-theater dinners before a show
  • Birthdays, anniversaries and nights out with friends

With dinner served until 1:00 am every night, a late table after a long day is never out of reach.

Private Events at a Midtown East Seafood Restaurant

For bigger occasions, The Alexander hosts everything from intimate dinners to full buyouts.

Event Options

  • Birthdays and celebrations with tailored menus
  • Corporate events with private or semi-private seating
  • Holiday parties with seasonal menus
  • Full buyouts with custom menus and a dedicated events team

That events team handles the details, so hosts can spend the evening with their guests instead of managing logistics.

Planning Your Visit

  • Address: 905 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022
  • Hours: Dinner daily, 4:00 pm to 1:00 am
  • Reservations: Book online or call +1-212-777-5161
  • Email: reservations@alexanderny.com

Online booking covers parties of 1 to 20, with an option for larger groups.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is The Alexander located?

At 905 1st Avenue, on the corner of 51st Street in Midtown East, a few minutes from the UN.

What kind of seafood does The Alexander serve?

Mediterranean seafood with Greek influences: oysters, crudo, ceviche, whole grilled branzino, dorado, snapper, salmon, miso black cod, tuna, scallops, prawns and lobster.

Are there options besides seafood?

Yes. The menu includes prime steaks such as a dry-aged strip, handcrafted Italian pastas, seasonal vegetables and baklava for dessert.

What are the hours?

Dinner is served daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am.

Can I book a private event?

Yes. The Alexander hosts birthdays, corporate events, holiday parties and full buyouts, with tailored menus and a dedicated events team.

How do I make a reservation?

Book online through the website or call +1-212-777-5161.

Your Next Seafood Restaurant in Midtown NYC Is on 1st Avenue

Great seafood doesn’t need a lot of dressing up. It needs a kitchen that buys well, cooks with a light hand and knows when to step back.

That’s what The Alexander does, night after night. Fresh catch from the Mediterranean and beyond, prime steaks for the table’s holdouts, a bar built on citrus and herbs, and a room that works for a client’s dinner or a birthday.

Whether it’s a pre-theater bite or a late dinner after work, there’s a table waiting. Reserve yours online or call +1-212-777-5161, and let the daily catch do the talking.

Posted in Deserts, Salads, Seafood
Write a comment

Table Reservation

* Powered by Powered by OpenTable