Reservation Reservation
Best Restaurant Midtown East
Visit Us
  • 905 1st Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
  • Dinner Time - 04:00 pm – 01:00 am

Reading a Seafood Restaurant Menu Like a Regular: What to Order at The Alexander

November 15, 2026

A good seafood restaurant menu tells you a lot before the first plate lands. It shows what came in that morning, how much the kitchen trusts it, and how it wants you to eat. At The Alexander, on the corner of 1st Avenue and 51st Street in Midtown East, the menu reads like a walk along the Mediterranean coast, starting cold at the raw bar and finishing at the grill.

The short answer: The Alexander’s menu is built around fish and shellfish chosen daily and prepared simply with citrus, olive oil, and fresh herbs. It runs from a raw bar and crudo plates to whole grilled fish, handcrafted seafood pasta, and prime steaks, backed by Mediterranean-inspired cocktails and a Greek, Italian, and international wine list.

What Makes a Seafood Restaurant Menu Worth Your Evening?

Freshness comes first, restraint second. The Alexander’s whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond, and the kitchen, led by Master Chef Lorenzo, lets that quality speak with Greek-inspired seasoning rather than heavy sauces.

When you scan any seafood menu, a few signs separate a memorable dinner from an average one:

  • A raw bar that gives you real choice, from oysters to ceviche
  • Whole fish cooked on the bone, not just fillets
  • Good options for guests who don’t eat seafood
  • A drinks list built to work with the food

The Alexander covers all four.

Start Cold: The Raw Bar and Crudo Plates

Seafood Towers for the Table

If you are dining with friends or clients, a tower sets the tone. The Deluxe Tower brings oysters, clams, shrimp, half a lobster, and ceviche with three sauces. The Royal Tower scales up for bigger groups with a whole lobster and a ceviche trio.

Prefer something smaller? Shrimp cocktail, a lobster tostada, caviar, and steamed mussels or clams are all on hand.

Crudo, Ceviche, and Tartare

This is where the kitchen’s light touch shows best. A few standouts:

  • Faroe Island salmon crudo with citrus vinegar, serrano peppers, and orange
  • Tuna sashimi with tamari soy, jalapeño, cilantro, and sesame
  • Hamachi ceviche with avocado, cucumber, and mango chutney
  • Scallops carpaccio with preserved lemon, Aleppo pepper, and black lava salt
  • Octopus carpaccio with roasted peppers, capers, and crispy shallots

Ordering two or three plates for the table is the easiest way to taste the range without filling up early.

The Heart of the Seafood Restaurant Menu: Whole Fish From the Grill

Whole fish is the clearest test of a seafood kitchen, and it is the centerpiece here. Branzino, dorade, and snapper come off the grill with roasted lemon potatoes and a lemon caper sauce. There is also a salt-baked option at market price.

If a whole fish feels like too much, the menu offers Faroe Island salmon with charred string beans, miso black cod, tuna, scallops with risotto, and grilled prawns.

Before the mains, consider a first course: grilled octopus, calamari served grilled or fried, crab cakes with harissa romesco, or Shrimp Santorini.

Handcrafted Pasta With a Coastal Accent

The Italian side of the menu leans fully into the sea:

  • Linguini alle vongole with clams, cherry tomatoes, parsley, and olive oil
  • Squid ink linguini with crabmeat in a cream sauce
  • Ocean linguini with shrimp, calamari, and mussels
  • Lobster pasta made with a whole lobster

Not Everyone Orders Fish, and That’s Fine

Groups rarely agree on one thing, so the menu makes room for everyone. Prime steaks include rib eye, New York strip, and filet mignon, along with surf and turf, lamb chops, and a 40 oz tomahawk built for sharing. There is also a half roasted chicken.

Vegan and vegetarian guests can choose from zucchini chips, crispy cauliflower, zoodle mushroom pasta, and eggplant steak. Sides such as roasted mushrooms, creamy artichoke spinach, and grilled asparagus round out any order.

Cocktails and Wine Made for Seafood

The bar works with fresh citrus and herbs, so the signature cocktails pair naturally with the raw bar. Try the Aquarelle with tequila, raspberry, and jalapeño, or the Forbidden Mezcal with grapefruit, yuzu, and plum salt.

The White Room, made with vodka, lychee, and elderflower, suits lighter crudo plates. For wine, the list focuses on Greek, Italian, and international labels chosen to match the menu.

When to Book: Dinners, Celebrations, and Private Events

The Alexander’s polished, lively dining room sits minutes from the UN, which makes it a natural fit for client dinners, pre-theater meals, and celebrations.

For bigger occasions, the team hosts:

  • Birthdays and celebrations with tailored menus
  • Corporate events, from client dinners to team gatherings
  • Holiday parties with seasonal menus
  • Full buyouts with custom menus and a dedicated events team

Final Thoughts

A seafood restaurant menu is only as good as the fish behind it and the restraint of the kitchen cooking it. The Alexander gets both right, pairing daily-selected seafood with Mediterranean simplicity and warm, attentive service in the heart of Midtown East.

Whether you are planning a quiet dinner for two or a full event, the best next step is simple: reserve your table online or call +1-212-777-5161, and let the day’s catch decide the rest.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is on The Alexander’s seafood restaurant menu?

A raw bar with seafood towers, crudo and ceviche, whole grilled fish, seafood pasta, prime steaks, and Mediterranean-inspired cocktails.

Where is The Alexander located?

At 905 1st Avenue, on the corner of 51st Street in Midtown East, New York, minutes from the UN.

Is the seafood fresh?

Yes. Whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond, and the kitchen selects the catch each morning.

Are there options for guests who don’t eat seafood?

Yes. The menu includes prime steaks, lamb chops, roasted chicken, and vegan and vegetarian dishes such as eggplant steak and zoodle mushroom pasta.

Can I host a private event at The Alexander?

Yes. The team hosts birthdays, corporate events, holiday parties, and full buyouts with custom menus.

How do I make a reservation?

Book online through the reservations page, call +1-212-777-5161, or email reservations@alexanderny.com.

Posted in Deserts, Salads, Seafood
Write a comment

Table Reservation

* Powered by Powered by OpenTable