The Alexander, at 905 1st Avenue and 51st Street, is a Mediterranean seafood restaurant open daily from 4 pm to 1 am. It is known for whole grilled fish, raw bar towers, crudo, handcrafted seafood pasta, prime steaks, signature cocktails and private dining for celebrations and corporate events.
Midtown East has no shortage of places to eat. What it has fewer of is a room you can walk into at 6 pm after a long day, order oysters and a cold cocktail, and still be glad you stayed for dinner at 9.
That is the gap Alexander fills. If you are searching for the best restaurant in Midtown East and seafood is what you crave, this corner of 1st Avenue deserves a closer look. Here is what to order, when to go and how to make the most of it.
Why The Alexander Is the Best Restaurant Midtown East Diners Keep Recommending
Great seafood restaurants are rarely complicated. They buy well, cook with restraint and let the fish speak. That is the philosophy behind The Alexander.
A Kitchen Built Around the Day’s Catch
Each morning, the kitchen selects the day’s finest fish and shellfish, flown in from the Mediterranean and beyond. Preparations lean on Greek influences: bright citrus, good olive oil and fresh herbs.
The result is food that tastes clean and confident, never fussy.
A Room That Works for Business and Pleasure
The dining room is lively and polished, just minutes from the UN. It suits a client’s dinner as easily as a date night, a pre-theater meal or a birthday with friends. Service is attentive without hovering, which matters more than most people admit.
A Fresh Fish Restaurant NYC Seafood Lovers Should Know About
Plenty of menus list “fresh fish.” Fewer build the whole experience around it. If you want a true fresh fish restaurant NYC locals can rely on, here is how to order at The Alexander.
Start at the Raw Bar
The raw bar sets the tone for the evening. A few standouts:
- Deluxe Tower: oysters, clams, shrimp, half a lobster and ceviche, served with mignonette, cocktail sauce and chili oil
- Royal Tower: the bigger version, built for a group that wants to linger
- Crudo plates: hamachi with Nardello peppers and chili oil, sashimi-grade tuna with tamari and jalapeño, or scallop carpaccio with preserved lemon and Aleppo pepper
- Ceviche: shrimp, hamachi or razor clam, each with its own citrus profile
A tower plus two crudo plates is a smart way to open a table of four.
Then Order the Whole Fish
This is the heart of the menu. Whole grilled branzino, dorade and snapper arrive with roasted lemon potatoes and a lemon caper sauce. There is also a salt-baked fish, priced at market.
If whole fish is not your thing, miso black cod with pickled ginger, Faroe Island salmon with charred string beans, or scallops over creamy risotto with garlicky chili oil are all strong choices.
Pasta, Steaks and Something for Everyone
Not everyone at the table wants seafood, and Alexander plans for that. Handcrafted pastas include linguini alle vongole, squid ink linguini with crabmeat and a lobster pasta made with a whole lobster.
On the land side, there are prime steaks, surf and turf and a half roasted chicken. Plant-based guests can choose zoodle mushroom pasta or an eggplant steak with oven-roasted vegetables.
Searching for the Best Happy Hour in Midtown? Start With Cocktails at 4 PM
The doors open at 4 pm every day, which makes The Alexander an easy after-work stop. If you are hunting for the best happy hour in Midtown, a bar seat, a crudo plate and a well-made cocktail is a hard combination to beat.
The Signature Cocktails 2026 list is worth exploring:
- Aquarelle: tequila blanco, raspberry and jalapeño with a Tajín rim
- Forbidden Mezcal: smoky mezcal, yuzu and grapefruit
- Le Souk: bourbon, peach liqueur and Amaro Nonino, finished with a flamed orange
- Dejavu: rum, lychee and yuzu with a tropical lift
- Andrew Steak: a silky espresso martini for the late crowd
Prefer wine? The list leans on Greek, Italian and international labels chosen to match the food.
A practical tip: happy hour offerings and timings can change, so call ahead at +1-212-777-5161 to confirm what is on before you go.
Private Dining and Events in Midtown East
With the holiday season close, now is the time to lock in a date. The Alexander hosts:
- Birthdays and celebrations: anniversaries, engagements and milestone birthdays with a tailored menu
- Corporate events: client dinners and team celebrations with private or semi-private seating
- Holiday parties: festive seasonal menus in a lively, elegant setting
- Full buyouts: the entire restaurant for larger groups, with custom menus and a dedicated events team
Know Before You Go
- Address: 905 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022, at 51st Street
- Hours: daily, 4 pm to 1 am
- Reservations: book online or call +1-212-777-5161
- Best for: after-work drinks, pre-theater dinners, client meals and late-night seafood
The Final Word
The best restaurant in Midtown East is not the loudest or the most hyped. It is the one that gets the basics right every night: great fish, honest cooking, thoughtful drinks and people who look after you.
That is what Alexander does, from the first oyster at 4 pm to the last espresso martini before 1 am. Reserve your table and see where the sea meets Manhattan.
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes The Alexander the best restaurant in Midtown East for seafood?
Fish and shellfish are selected daily and flown in from the Mediterranean and beyond, then prepared simply with citrus, olive oil and herbs. Add a raw bar, handcrafted pasta, prime steaks and attentive service, and it covers every kind of evening.
Is The Alexander a good fresh fish restaurant in NYC?
Yes. The menu features whole grilled branzino, dorade and snapper, a salt-baked fish, plus Faroe Island salmon, miso black cod, tuna and scallops.
Does The Alexander offer happy hour in Midtown?
The restaurant opens at 4 pm daily, making it a popular after-work stop for cocktails and raw bar plates. For current happy hour offerings and timings, call +1-212-777-5161 before visiting.
What are Alexander’s hours?
The Alexander is open daily from 4 pm to 1 am.
Can I host a private event at The Alexander?
Yes. The team hosts birthdays, corporate dinners, holiday parties and full buyouts, with tailored menus and private or semi-private seating.
Where is Alexander located?
905 1st Avenue at 51st Street, New York, NY 10022, in Midtown East and minutes from the UN.