Reservation Reservation
Best Restaurant Midtown East
Visit Us
  • 905 1st Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
  • Dinner Time - 04:00 pm – 01:00 am

Hunting for the Best Food in New York? Here’s Why Seafood Lovers Keep Ending Up at The Alexander

October 14, 2026

Ask ten New Yorkers where to find the best food in New York and you’ll get ten different answers, plus a friendly argument or two. But when the craving is fresh seafood done properly, that list gets a lot shorter.

On the corner of 1st Avenue and 51st Street in Midtown East, The Alexander has built its reputation on a simple idea: start with the day’s finest fish and shellfish, then let Mediterranean cooking do the rest.

The short answer: The Alexander is a Mediterranean seafood restaurant at 905 1st Avenue, open daily from 5pm to 1am. Its raw bar, crudo plates, whole grilled fish, handcrafted pastas and prime steaks make it a strong choice for anyone looking for the best food in New York with a seafood focus.

What Really Defines the Best Food in New York?

It’s rarely the longest menu or the loudest room. Great seafood comes down to sourcing, restraint and a kitchen that knows when to stop.

When you’re choosing where to eat, look for:

  • Freshness you can taste: fish and shellfish selected daily
  • Simple preparation: citrus, olive oil and herbs instead of heavy sauces
  • Range: good options for guests who don’t eat seafood
  • Service that respects your time: whether it’s a long dinner or a quick bite before a show

Alexander checks every one of those boxes. Each morning, the kitchen selects whole fish and shellfish flown in from the Mediterranean and beyond, then prepares them with Greek influences of bright citrus, olive oil and fresh herbs.

A Seafood Menu Built Around the Day’s Catch

The Raw Bar: Where Most Tables Begin

If you’re sharing, start here. The Deluxe Tower ($92) brings six oysters, six clams, three shrimp, half a lobster and a ceviche, served with mignonette, cocktail sauce and chili oil.

Bigger group? The Royal Tower ($169) doubles down with a full lobster and a ceviche trio. Caviar, shrimp cocktail and a lobster tostada round out the section.

Crudo and Ceviche for Lighter Appetites

The crudo plates show how much a kitchen can do with very little. A few standouts:

  • Faroe Island salmon with citrus vinegar, serrano peppers and orange
  • Sashimi-grade tuna with tamari, jalapeño and sesame
  • Hamachi ceviche with avocado, cucumber and mango chutney
  • Scallop carpaccio with preserved lemon and Aleppo pepper

Whole Grilled Fish, Mediterranean Style

This is the heart of the menu. Branzino (34),Dorade(36) and Snapper ($43) arrive whole and grilled, served with roasted lemon potatoes and lemon caper sauce. There’s also a salt-baked option at market price.

If you’d rather skip the bones, the miso black cod and the scallops over creamy risotto are both worth ordering.

Why The Alexander Ranks Among the Top Seafood Restaurants in Midtown

Plenty of top seafood restaurants do one thing well. The Alexander’s real strength is balance, which matters when you’re booking for a table where not everyone wants fish.

  • Handcrafted pasta: linguini alle vongole, squid ink linguini with crabmeat, Ocean Linguini and a Lobster Pasta made with a whole lobster ($46)
  • Prime steaks: filet mignon, New York strip, rib eye, a 40oz tomahawk and surf and turf
  • Plant-based plates: zoodle mushroom pasta, eggplant steak and a roasted vegetable mélange

That range is a big part of what separates good seafood spots from the top seafood restaurants people return to.

Signature Cocktails and a Wine List Worth Lingering Over

The bar takes its job seriously. Signature cocktails are crafted with fresh citrus and herbs, and a few have real personality:

  • Forbidden Mezcal: smoky mezcal, yuzu, grapefruit and a touch of plum salt
  • Le Souk: bourbon, peach liqueur and Amaro Nonino, finished with a flamed dehydrated orange
  • White Room: vodka, lychee and elderflower, silky and refined

The wine list leans on Greek, Italian and international labels chosen to pair with the menu, so a glass of something crisp alongside grilled fish is never a guess.

The Room, the Location and the Pace of the Evening

The dining room is lively and polished, just minutes from the UN. It works equally well for a client dinner, a pre-theater meal or a celebration that runs late.

And late is the key word. The Alexander serves until 1am every night, which is rare for a restaurant of this calibre in Midtown East.

Private Dining and Events in Midtown East

The Alexander also hosts private events with tailored menus and attentive service:

  • Birthdays and celebrations: milestone birthdays, anniversaries and engagements
  • Corporate events: client dinners and team celebrations with private or semi-private seating
  • Holiday parties: festive seasonal menus for company or family gatherings
  • Full buyouts: the entire restaurant, with custom menus and a dedicated events team

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I find the best food in New York for seafood?

The Alexander at 905 1st Avenue in Midtown East is a strong pick, with a full raw bar, crudo plates and whole grilled Mediterranean fish.

Is The Alexander one of the top seafood restaurants in Midtown?

Yes. Its daily fish selection, raw bar towers and Greek-influenced preparations put it among the top seafood restaurants in Midtown East.

What are The Alexander’s hours?

The Alexander is open daily from 5pm to 1am.

Are there options for guests who don’t eat seafood?

Yes. The menu includes prime steaks, roasted chicken, handcrafted pastas and plant-based dishes like eggplant steak and zoodle mushroom pasta.

Can I book a private event at The Alexander?

Yes. The restaurant hosts birthdays, corporate dinners, holiday parties and full buyouts with custom menus and a dedicated events team.

Final Thoughts

The best food in New York doesn’t have to be complicated. Sometimes it’s a tower of just-shucked oysters, a whole branzino finished with lemon and olive oil, and a well-made cocktail in a room that stays open late.

That’s exactly what The Alexander does, night after night, in the heart of Midtown East.

Ready to taste it for yourself? Reserve your table online or call +1-212-777-5161 to plan your next dinner or private event.

Posted in Deserts, Salads, Seafood
Write a comment

Table Reservation

* Powered by Powered by OpenTable