Reservation Reservation
Best Restaurant Midtown East
Visit Us
  • 905 1st Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
  • Dinner Time - 04:00 pm – 01:00 am

Seafood Restaurant Midtown NYC: What to Order, When to Go, and Why The Alexander Stands Out

November 12, 2026

If you want a seafood restaurant Midtown NYC that takes the catch seriously, The Alexander at 1st Avenue and 51st Street is a strong pick. It’s a Mediterranean seafood restaurant in Midtown East serving the day’s fish and shellfish, a full raw bar, handcrafted pasta, prime steaks, and signature cocktails, open daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am.

That’s the short version. Here’s what actually makes the table worth booking.

What Makes a Great Seafood Restaurant in Midtown NYC?

Midtown has no shortage of places to eat. What’s harder to find is a room where the fish is the reason you came, not an afterthought on a long menu.

When regulars judge a seafood spot, they tend to look at three things:

  • Freshness you can taste. Fish that’s chosen daily and cooked without hiding it under heavy sauces.
  • Range. Raw, grilled, whole, or tossed through pasta, depending on the night and the appetite.
  • The room itself. Service and atmosphere that suit a client’s dinner as well as a birthday.

The Alexander was built around all three.

Inside The Alexander: Mediterranean Seafood in Midtown East

Each morning, the kitchen selects the day’s fish and shellfish. Whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond, then prepared simply with Greek influences: citrus, olive oil, and herbs.

The kitchen is led by Master Chef Lorenzo, whose cooking leans on precision and restraint. The idea is simple. When the fish is this fresh, you let it speak.

The dining room matches that confidence. It’s lively and polished, with attentive service and a warm feel that works whether you’re closing a deal or catching up with old friends.

The Seafood Menu, Course by Course

Start at the Raw Bar

The raw bar is where many tables begin, and for good reason. The Deluxe Tower brings oysters, clams, shrimp, half a lobster, and ceviche to the table. Larger groups often go for the Royal Tower.

Smaller plates include shrimp cocktail, lobster tostada, steamed mussels, steamed clams, and caviar.

Crudo, Ceviche, and Carpaccio

If you prefer something lighter, the crudo section is worth your attention:

  • Faroe Island salmon, sashimi-grade tuna, and hamachi crudo
  • Shrimp, hamachi, and razor clam ceviche
  • Salmon and tuna tartare
  • Scallop and octopus carpaccio

These plates are bright, clean, and easy to share.

Whole Fish: The Heart of the Menu

Ordering whole fish is the most Mediterranean way to eat here. Choose from Branzino, Dorade, Snapper, or the salt-baked option at market price. Each comes with roasted lemon potatoes and lemon caper sauce.

Prefer a fillet? The kitchen also serves Faroe Island salmon, miso black cod, tuna, scallops, and prawns.

Handcrafted Pasta and Prime Steaks

Seafood carries into the pasta, too. Linguini alle vongole, squid ink linguini, Ocean linguini, and lobster pasta are all made by hand.

Not everyone at the table wants fish, and that’s covered. Prime steaks include rib eye, New York strip, filet mignon, and a 40 oz tomahawk. Surf and turf split the difference nicely.

Cocktails and Wine That Suit the Sea

The bar crafts Mediterranean-inspired signature cocktails with fresh citrus and herbs. The 2026 list includes Aquarelle, Dejavu, White Room, Forbidden Mezcal, Le Souk, and the house namesake, The Alexander.

The wine list features Greek, Italian, and international labels chosen to pair with the menu. A crisp white with crudo, or something fuller alongside a steak, is easy to find.

When to Book: Dinner, Business, and Celebrations

Because The Alexander opens at 4:00 pm and serves until 1:00 am, it fits a lot of Midtown schedules:

  • Pre-theater dinner before a show
  • Business dinners a few minutes from the UN
  • Late seafood dinners after a long day in the office
  • Celebrations that call for a seafood tower and a round of cocktails

Private Events at a Midtown NYC Seafood Restaurant

The Alexander also hosts private and semi-private gatherings. Options include:

  • Birthdays and celebrations with tailored menus
  • Corporate events, including client dinners
  • Holiday parties with seasonal menus
  • Full buyouts for larger groups, with custom menus and a dedicated events team

Whether it’s an intimate dinner or the whole room, the team plans around your group.

A Few Insider Tips Before You Go

  • Share a tower first. It sets the pace and gives everyone a taste of the raw bar.
  • Ask about the day’s fish. Whole fish selection depends on what arrived that morning.
  • Book ahead for groups. Reservations are available online, by phone, or by email.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is The Alexander located?

The Alexander is at 905 1st Avenue, on the corner of 51st Street in Midtown East, just a few minutes from the UN.

What kind of seafood does The Alexander serve?

Mediterranean seafood with Greek influences, including a raw bar, crudo, ceviche, whole fish like Branzino and Dorade, and seafood pastas such as lobster pasta.

What are the opening hours?

The Alexander is open daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am.

Are there options for guests who don’t eat seafood?

Yes. The menu includes prime steaks, half roasted chicken, lamb chops, and several vegan-friendly dishes.

Can I book a private event at The Alexander?

Yes. The restaurant hosts birthdays, corporate dinners, holiday parties, and full buyouts, with tailored menus and a dedicated events team.

How do I make a reservation?

Book online through the reservations page, call +1-212-777-5161, or email reservations@alexanderny.com.

The Bottom Line

Finding a seafood restaurant Midtown NYC is easy. Finding one where the fish is chosen each morning, cooked with care, and served in a room you’ll want to return to is less common.

The Alexander brings Mediterranean seafood, handcrafted pasta, prime steaks, and thoughtful cocktails together at 905 1st Avenue. If you’re planning dinner, a client meeting, or a celebration in Midtown East, reserve your table and let the day’s catch do the rest.

Posted in Deserts, Salads, Seafood
Write a comment

Table Reservation

* Powered by Powered by OpenTable