If you want the best restaurant in Midtown for fresh seafood, The Alexander at 905 1st Avenue (at 51st Street) is a strong place to start. It serves Mediterranean seafood with Greek influences, from a raw bar and crudo to whole grilled fish, handmade pasta and prime steaks. The dining room is open daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am, a few minutes from the UN.
At a glance
- Cuisine: Mediterranean seafood, handcrafted pasta, prime steaks
- Location: 905 1st Avenue at 51st Street, Midtown East
- Hours: Daily, 4:00 pm to 1:00 am
- Best for: date nights, pre-theater dinners, client dinners, celebrations
- Reservations: (212) 777-5161 or reservations@alexanderny.com
Midtown has plenty of places to eat. Far fewer get the basics right every night: fish that tastes like the sea, service that reads the table, and a room you want to stay in.
That’s a fair test for any restaurant in this part of town, and it’s the standard The Alexander is built around.
What Makes Alexander the Best Restaurant in Midtown?
The short answer is freshness and range. The kitchen picks its fish and shellfish each morning, then prepares them simply with bright citrus, olive oil and fresh herbs.
Here’s what sets it apart:
- Fresh catch daily: whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond.
- A clear point of view: Greek-influenced seafood, handcrafted Italian pasta and prime steaks.
- The room: lively and polished without feeling stiff.
- Late hours: open until 1:00 am, so dinner fits around a show or a long workday.
Start at the Raw Bar
Most good evenings here start with something cold and shared. Order a round for the table before anyone opens the mains.
Seafood Towers Built for Sharing
The Deluxe Tower brings oysters, clams, shrimp, half a lobster and ceviche, with mignonette, cocktail sauce and chili oil. For a bigger group, the Royal Tower adds a whole lobster and a ceviche trio.
Smaller orders work too: shrimp cocktail, a lobster tostada, steamed mussels or caviar.
Crudo, Ceviche and Carpaccio
This is where the kitchen’s light touch shows. A few plates worth knowing:
- Sashimi-grade tuna with tamari, jalapeño, cilantro and sesame
- Hamachi ceviche with avocado, cucumber and mango chutney
- Scallops carpaccio with preserved lemon, Aleppo pepper and black lava salt
- Octopus carpaccio with roasted peppers, capers and crispy shallots
A practical tip: two or three crudo plates for the table beat one appetizer each. Everyone tastes more of the menu.
The Main Course: Whole Fish, Pasta and Prime Steaks
Grilled Whole Fish, the Mediterranean Way
Branzino, dorade and snapper come grilled whole with roasted lemon potatoes and a lemon caper sauce. There’s also a salt-baked fish at market price.
If you’d rather skip the bones, the miso black cod with pickled ginger and the scallops over creamy risotto with garlic chili oil are both easy picks.
Handcrafted Pasta
The pasta list is short and seafood-led. Linguini alle vongole, squid ink linguini with crabmeat, and Ocean Linguini with shrimp, calamari and mussels all sit on the menu. The Lobster Pasta comes with a whole lobster.
Steaks, Surf and Turf, and Plant-Based Plates
Not everyone at the table wants fish, and that’s covered. Prime steaks, surf and turf and a 40oz lamb chop tomahawk share the menu with a dedicated vegan section, including crispy cauliflower and eggplant steak.
That kind of range is what good food in NYC should look like when a group can’t agree on one thing.
Signature Cocktails and Wine
The bar leans Mediterranean in spirit. A few signature cocktails to try:
- Aquarelle: tequila, raspberry, jalapeño and lime
- Forbidden Mezcal: mezcal, grapefruit, yuzu and club soda
- Le Souk: bourbon, peach liqueur, amaro and bitters
- Andrew Steak: an espresso martini with vodka and Irish cream
The wine list covers Greek, Italian and international bottles, which suits a seafood-heavy table well.
Why It Belongs on Any Best Food in New York List
The best food in New York isn’t only about the plate. It’s about whether a restaurant works for the night you actually have planned.
Pre-Theater Dinners and Date Nights
Doors open at 4:00 pm, so an early dinner before a show is simple. Later in the evening, the room settles into a relaxed date-night pace.
Client Dinners and Corporate Events
The Alexander hosts client dinners, team celebrations and corporate events, with private or semi-private seating.
Birthdays, Holidays and Full Buyouts
Milestone birthdays, anniversaries and engagements get a tailored menu and attentive service. Holiday parties come with seasonal menus, and full buyouts include custom menus and a dedicated events team.
How to Plan Your Visit
- Reserve ahead online, or call (212) 777-5161, especially for weekends.
- Start with the raw bar, then share a whole fish.
- Planning a group event? Email reservations@alexanderny.com early.
- Asking about happy hour? Contact the restaurant for current details.
The Bottom Line
Finding good food in NYC isn’t hard. Finding one place that works for a date, a client and a family celebration is much harder.
The Alexander earns its spot as the best restaurant in Midtown by keeping things honest: fresh fish, simple preparation, real hospitality and a room with energy. When you’re ready to see for yourself, book a table and let the sea meet Manhattan.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is The Alexander located?
At 905 1st Avenue, on the corner of 51st Street in Midtown East, a few minutes from the United Nations.
What are The Alexander’s hours?
The restaurant is open daily from 4:00 pm to 1:00 am.
What kind of food does The Alexander serve?
Mediterranean seafood with Greek influences, including a raw bar, crudo, whole grilled fish, handcrafted pasta and prime steaks. There are also vegan dishes.
Is The Alexander the best restaurant in Midtown for seafood?
For fresh, simply prepared seafood, it’s a top pick. Whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond.
Is it a good choice for a pre-theater dinner?
Yes. Doors open at 4:00 pm, which makes an early dinner before a show easy to plan.
Does The Alexander host private events?
Yes. It hosts birthdays, anniversaries, engagements, corporate events, holiday parties and full buyouts with tailored menus.
How do I make a reservation?
Book on the reservations page, call (212) 777-5161 or email reservations@alexanderny.com.