Reservation Reservation
Best Restaurant Midtown East
Visit Us
  • 905 1st Avenue,
    New York, NY 10022
  • Dinner Time - 04:00 pm – 01:00 am

What Should You Order From a Seafood Menu NYC Locals Trust? A Plate-by-Plate Guide to The Alexander

October 27, 2026

The best seafood menu NYC diners keep coming back to isn’t the longest one in town. It’s the one where you can tell, from the first glance, that someone chose the fish that morning.

That is how Alexander works. On the corner of 1st Avenue and 51st Street in Midtown East, the kitchen builds its menu around whole fish and shellfish flown in daily from the Mediterranean and beyond. Here’s how to read it like a regular.

The Quick Answer: What Makes This Seafood Menu NYC-Worthy

The Alexander is a Mediterranean seafood restaurant in Midtown East, open daily from 4 pm to 1 am. Its menu is built around five things:

  • A raw bar with oysters, clams, shrimp, lobster and ceviche, including two seafood towers
  • Crudo plates like hamachi, sashimi-grade tuna, salmon tartare and scallop carpaccio
  • Whole grilled fish, including branzino, dorade, snapper and a salt-baked catch
  • Handcrafted seafood pastas, from linguini alle vongole to a whole-lobster pasta
  • Prime steaks and signature cocktails for the rest of the table

Start Cold: The Raw Bar and Crudo

On most seafood restaurant menu, raw fish is the warm-up. Here, it can easily be the whole evening.

The Deluxe Tower brings oysters, clams, shrimp, half a lobster and ceviche, served with mignonette, cocktail sauce and chili oil. The Royal Tower goes bigger, with a whole lobster and a ceviche trio. It’s built for a table that likes to share.

Crudo Worth Slowing Down For

The crudo section is where the Greek influence comes through. Citrus, olive oil and fresh herbs do the work, and the fish stays front and center. A few to know:

  • Hamachi crudo or hamachi ceviche
  • Sashimi-grade tuna, or tuna tartare
  • Scallops carpaccio and octopus carpaccio
  • Shrimp ceviche, bright and sharp

A practical tip: two crudos and a shrimp cocktail make a light, complete dinner, especially when you’re watching the clock.

Whole Grilled Fish, Done the Mediterranean Way

Ask guests what they remember, and the whole grilled branzino comes up again and again. It arrives simply grilled, with roasted lemon potatoes and a lemon caper sauce. No heavy sauces, nothing hiding the fish.

Dorade and snapper follow the same approach. There’s also a salt-baked option at market price, which is worth asking about when you sit down.

Prefer a fillet? Faroe Island salmon, miso black cod, tuna, scallops and grilled prawns cover everything from rich and buttery to clean and lean.

Pastas That Carry the Sea

The handcrafted pasta list is short and focused:

  • Linguini alle vongole
  • Squid ink linguini with crabmeat
  • Ocean linguini
  • Lobster pasta, made with a whole lobster

Room at the Table for Everyone

A restaurant menu seafood lovers can bring their whole group to needs range, and this one has it. Prime steaks include rib eye, New York strip, filet mignon and a 40 oz tomahawk, along with lamb chops and a surf and turf that splits the difference.

There’s a half roasted chicken, three salads, and a “Vegan and Friends” section with crispy cauliflower, eggplant steak and a zoodle mushroom pasta. Sides like grilled asparagus and creamy artichoke spinach round things out.

Cocktails Made to Sit Next to Seafood

The bar works with fresh citrus and herbs, which is exactly what seafood wants beside it. A few signature cocktails:

  • Forbidden Mezcal: mezcal, grapefruit, yuzu and a splash of soda
  • White Room: vodka, lychee, elderflower and lime
  • Aquarelle: tequila, raspberry, jalapeño and agave
  • Le Souk: bourbon, peach liqueur, amaro and bitters, stirred over ice

Brighter drinks suit the raw bar and crudo. Save Le Souk for the steak. The wine list adds Greek, Italian and international labels if you’d rather pour a glass.

Seafood Menu NYC Tips: How to Order for Any Occasion

The same menu works very differently depending on the night you’re planning.

  • Client dinner: Start with a Deluxe Tower for the table, then let each guest pick a whole fish or a steak. It keeps things relaxed without slowing the conversation.
  • Pre-theater: Order crudo and one whole fish to share, and tell your server your curtain time.
  • Celebration: The Royal Tower, lobster pasta and a round of signature cocktails set the tone quickly.
  • Mixed group: Lean on surf and turf and the Vegan and Friends plates so nobody is ordering around the menu.

When the Table Gets Bigger: Private Events

The Alexander hosts birthdays, corporate events, holiday parties and full buyouts. A dedicated events team handles tailored menus, with private or semi-private seating for client dinners and larger groups. Your guests eat from the same kitchen that runs the dining room every night.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is on The Alexander’s seafood menu?

A raw bar with seafood towers, crudo and ceviche, whole grilled fish, seafood pastas and fillets like miso black cod and Faroe Island salmon.

What dish should I order on a first visit?

The whole grilled branzino. It is the dish guests mention most, served with roasted lemon potatoes and lemon caper sauce.

Does The Alexander have a raw bar?

Yes. It offers oysters, clams, shrimp cocktail, caviar, lobster tostada and two seafood towers for sharing.

Are there options for guests who don’t eat seafood?

Yes. The menu includes prime steaks, lamb chops, roasted chicken, salads and a dedicated vegan section.

What are The Alexander’s hours?

The restaurant is open daily from 4 pm to 1 am at 905 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022.

Can I book a private event at The Alexander?

Yes. It hosts birthdays, corporate dinners, holiday parties and full buyouts, with custom menus from a dedicated events team.

The Bottom Line

A great seafood menu in NYC comes down to a few honest things: fish that arrived that day, cooking that lets it speak, and a room that makes you want to stay for one more glass. The Alexander keeps it that simple, and that is why the branzino, the towers and the lobster pasta keep people coming back.

If you’re planning a client dinner, a pre-theater bite or a night worth celebrating, reserve a table online or through OpenTable, or call +1-212-777-5161. Bring an appetite and start with the raw bar.

Posted in Deserts, Salads, Seafood
Write a comment

Table Reservation

* Powered by Powered by OpenTable