The best seafood menu NYC has to offer rarely tries to do everything. It starts with what arrived that morning, and it has the confidence to leave good fish alone. That is the thinking behind The Alexander, a Mediterranean seafood restaurant on the corner of 1st Avenue and 51st Street in Midtown East.
Below is how the menu is built, what to order at each stage of the night, and how to plan anything from an after-work drink to a full private buyout.
The Quick Answer
The Alexander’s seafood menu is built around the day’s freshest fish and shellfish, simply prepared with Greek and Mediterranean influences. The highlights:
- Raw bar: oysters, shrimp cocktail, caviar, and Deluxe and Royal seafood towers
- Crudo and ceviche: tuna, hamachi, salmon tartare, scallop and octopus carpaccio
- Whole grilled fish: Branzino, Dorade, Snapper, and salt-baked fish at market price
- Handcrafted pasta: Linguini alle Vongole, Squid Ink Linguini, Ocean Linguini, Lobster Pasta
- Where and when: 905 1st Avenue, Midtown East, with dinner served daily from 4 pm to 1 am
Why This Seafood Menu in NYC Starts With the Morning Catch
Every morning, the kitchen chooses the day’s fish and shellfish. Whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and other regions, and the menu takes its cue from what comes through the door.
The cooking style is deliberately restrained. Bright citrus, good olive oil and fresh herbs do the work, so the quality of the fish is what you actually taste. Under Master Chef Lorenzo, that restraint is the point rather than a shortcut.
Working Through the Menu, Course by Course
A seafood dinner here works best when you treat it as a progression, moving from cold and clean to warm and rich.
Start at the Raw Bar
The raw bar sets the tone. Shrimp cocktail, steamed mussels and clams, and a lobster tostada are easy openers for two. For a group, the Deluxe Tower or the Royal Tower turns the first round into a shared centerpiece, and caviar is there if the occasion calls for it.
Crudo and Ceviche for the Table
This is where the kitchen’s light touch shows best. Sashimi-grade tuna, hamachi and Faroe Island salmon arrive as crudo, alongside shrimp and hamachi ceviche, salmon and tuna tartare, and scallop or octopus carpaccio. Order two or three and pass them around.
The Whole Fish Is the Main Event
Whole grilled Branzino, Dorade and Snapper are the dishes that define the room. A salt-baked fish, priced at market, is a good choice for a slower dinner. If you prefer a fillet, there is Faroe Island salmon, Miso Black Cod, tuna, scallops and grilled prawns.
Pasta, Steaks and Plates for Everyone Else
Not everyone at the table wants fish, and the menu accounts for that. Handcrafted pastas run from clams to squid ink to a Lobster Pasta that bridges both worlds. Prime steaks include a New York Strip, Filet Mignon, a 40 oz Tomahawk and Surf and Turf, while vegan guests can turn to crispy cauliflower, zucchini chips or a zoodle mushroom pasta.
Choosing a Fresh Fish Restaurant in NYC: What to Look For
Plenty of places call themselves a fresh fish restaurant NYC. A few practical signs separate the real thing:
- Whole fish on the menu. Serving fish whole means the kitchen has nothing to hide.
- A market-price item. It shows the menu moves with what is available, not a fixed order sheet.
- Simple preparations. Citrus, olive oil and herbs only work when the fish is good.
- Staff who know the catch. Ask what came in today. The answer tells you a lot.
At The Alexander, all four are part of an ordinary dinner.
After Work at the Bar: Cocktails, Oysters and Happy Hour in Midtown
Doors open in the late afternoon, which makes the bar a natural stop for anyone working around Midtown East or near the United Nations, a short walk away. The signature cocktails are Mediterranean-inspired and built with fresh citrus and herbs. Look for names like Aquarelle, Dejavu, Le Souk, Forbidden Mezcal and The Alexander.
A round of oysters with a cocktail is about as good as an early evening gets. If you are searching for the best happy hour in Midtown, contact the restaurant directly for current happy hour details before you go, since offerings can change. The wine list adds Greek, Italian and international labels to the mix.
Private Dining and Events in Midtown East
The same menu travels well beyond a table for two. The Alexander hosts:
- Birthdays and celebrations, including anniversaries and engagements, with tailored menus
- Corporate events, from client dinners to team celebrations, with private or semi-private seating
- Holiday parties with seasonal menus for company or family gatherings
- Full buyouts with custom menus and a dedicated events team
Private dining accommodates roughly 10 to 120 guests, so an intimate dinner and a large party are both on the table.
Where the Sea Meets Manhattan
A great seafood menu is less about length and more about trust: trust that the fish is fresh, that the kitchen knows when to stop, and that the room will look after you. That is what The Alexander has built on 1st Avenue.
Whether you are planning a quiet dinner, an after-work round of oysters, or an evening for 100 guests, the table is ready. Call +1 212-777-5161 or book online to reserve yours.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is on The Alexander’s seafood menu in NYC?
The menu includes a raw bar with oysters and seafood towers, crudo and ceviche, whole grilled Branzino, Dorade and Snapper, plus handcrafted seafood pastas like Lobster Pasta.
Is The Alexander a fresh fish restaurant in NYC?
Yes. The kitchen selects fish and shellfish every morning, and whole fish and shellfish are flown in daily from the Mediterranean and other regions.
Does The Alexander offer happy hour in Midtown?
The bar serves Mediterranean-inspired signature cocktails, wines and spirits. For current happy hour details, contact the restaurant directly before your visit.
Where is The Alexander located?
The restaurant is at 905 1st Avenue, on the corner of 51st Street in Midtown East, a short walk from the United Nations.
Are there options for guests who don’t eat seafood?
Yes. The menu includes prime steaks, half roasted chicken, handcrafted pastas and vegan dishes such as crispy cauliflower and zoodle mushroom pasta.
Can I book a private event at The Alexander?
Yes. The Alexander hosts birthdays, corporate events, holiday parties and full buyouts, with tailored menus for roughly 10 to 120 guests.